Wet’suwet’en Nation chiefs who oppose the $6.2-billion Coastal GasLink pipeline route in British Columbia stripped hereditary titles away from three Indigenous women who support the project.
The women formed the Wet’suwet’en Matrilineal Coalition (WMC) in August, 2015, hoping the fledgling group would address the need for a collective decision-making body. Internal strife within the Wet’suwet’en Nation has grown in recent years, with conflict between hereditary chiefs administering their unceded territories (passed down through oral traditions) versus elected band councillors on reserves (codified by federal law). It has placed a spotlight on the challenges faced by resource companies and governments when pursuing energy megaprojects in British Columbia.
The women say they have been ostracized behind the scenes since forming WMC and want to bring their case into the public light.
WMC incorporated as a not-for-profit group, with Gloria George, Darlene Glaim and Theresa Tait-Day serving as the original directors.
The three Indigenous women say they launched WMC in an effort to encourage Wet’suwet’en members to make informed decisions about contentious issues such as TransCanada Corp.'s Coastal GasLink. They say they tried unsuccessfully to persuade the male hereditary leaders to sign a benefits agreement with the natural-gas pipeline project.
The existence of WMC is a sign of a deeply divided nation, underscoring the complexity of the situation, according to Claire Marshall, a consultant retained by Coastal GasLink since 2012. Hereditary chiefs say non-Indigenous opposition from environmentalists to Hollywood celebrities is mounting against plans for the 670-kilometre route from northeast British Columbia to Kitimat on the West Coast.
The Office of the Wet’suwet’en, based in Smithers, B.C., is the umbrella organization that represents hereditary house groups.
Two of the Indigenous women were Wet’suwet’en house chiefs: Ms. George held the hereditary title Smogelgem under Sun House of the Laksamshu clan, while Ms. Glaim served as Woos under Grizzly House of the Gitdumden (also spelled Gidimt’en) clan.
“We established the matrilineal coalition, and the reason for that was to try to bring economic benefits to our young people,” Ms. George said.
Ms. Tait-Day held the hereditary position Wi’hali’yte, a spiritual name that means “far seer,” under House Beside The Fire of the Laksilyu clan.
The pipeline project has been approved by all 20 elected First Nation councils along the route, including five elected band councils that belong to the Wet’suwet’en Nation.
But five prominent Wet’suwet’en hereditary chiefs have led a campaign to oppose the pipeline and they accuse WMC of being biased because Coastal GasLink and the previous BC Liberal government each provided $30,000 in funding in 2017 to the group. Coastal GasLink has tried to bypass and undermine the authority of Wet’suwet’en hereditary chiefs, according to supporters of the Unist’ot’en protest camp. Unist’ot’en is affiliated with Dark House, one of 13 Wet’suwet’en hereditary house groups.
On the Wet’suwet’en’s unceded territory, the Unist’ot’en camp’s blockade had prevented Coastal GasLink workers from crossing the Morice River bridge in the B.C. Interior. The blockade on the bridge came down on Jan. 11, four days after the RCMP arrested 14 protesters at a police checkpoint along a remote B.C. logging road that leads to the Unist’ot’en camp.
Ms. George, Ms. Glaim and Ms. Tait-Day said in recent interviews with The Globe and Mail that the male hereditary chiefs have unfairly removed the Indigenous titles from them.
They have felt the repercussions of losing their titles, with WMC being excluded from important meetings. The previous BC Liberal government recognized the three women’s hereditary roles as recently as the spring of 2017. In May, 2018, the BC NDP government’s Indigenous Relations Minister Scott Fraser met with Wet’suwet’en hereditary leaders, but the gathering did not include the three women.
The pipeline is scheduled to be completed in late 2023. Royal Dutch Shell PLC-led LNG Canada has started construction on its $18-billion terminal in Kitimat, with the facility slated to start exporting liquefied natural gas to Asia by early 2025.
The Unist’ot’en camp has been endorsed by five prominent Wet’suwet’en house chiefs, part of a hereditary system of 13 house groups that fall under five clans. The five men (with their Indigenous title, followed by their house group and clan) are: John Ridsdale (Na’Moks) from Rafters on Beaver House under the Tsayu clan; Warner William (Knedebeas) from Dark House under the Gilseyhu clan; Jeff Brown (Madeek) from Where it Lies Blocking the Trail under the Gitdumden clan; Ron Mitchell (Hagwilnegh) from House of Many Eyes under the Laksilyu clan; and Warner Naziel (Smogelgem) from Sun House under the Laksamshu clan.
Mr. Naziel took over the Smogelgem title from Ms. George.
“Our matrilineal coalition tried to have talks with these guys. We cannot have the guys making decisions about our nation without proper engagement," Ms. Tait-Day said. "Every one of us women inherited our names through our family.”
Ms. Glaim temporarily stepped down from WMC in 2017, citing “turmoil” within the Wet’suwet’en Nation, before rejoining the coalition. “Our system is broken," Ms. Glaim said. "Our hereditary and elected band council systems don’t have a way to come together to agree or disagree. We don’t have unity and we’re a split nation, and that’s the sad part.”
Michael Lee Ross, a lawyer who represents two of the Unist’ot’en supporters, criticized the matrilineal coalition in a recent filing in B.C. Supreme Court. “WMC includes individuals who have improperly represented themselves as hereditary chiefs and who in consequence have been reprimanded and ordered to stop using a hereditary chiefly title or formally stripped of the claimed chiefly title,” said Mr. Ross, who represents Mr. Naziel and his spouse, Freda Huson.
Mr. Ross made his arguments in documents dated Feb. 20, filed in response to Coastal GasLink’s application for an interim court injunction to dismantle the Unist’ot’en blockade. Coastal GasLink names Mr. Naziel and Ms. Huson as defendants in the court case. Ms. Huson is a spokeswoman for the Unist’ot’en camp and Dark House, and also serves as an elected Witset councillor.
Mr. William, the Dark House chief, is also a long-time elected councillor with the Witset band, where a majority of councillors voted to support Coastal GasLink. “Coastal GasLink has attempted to subvert the authority of the Wet’suwet’en hereditary chiefs, including Knedebeas of Dark House specifically,” Mr. Ross said. “By funding and engaging with the WMC, Coastal GasLink has attempted to side-step Dark House, the Office of the Wet’suwet’en and Wet’suwet’en legal process."
Mr. Ridsdale, the Rafters on Beaver House chief, said protests and other strategies to combat Coastal GasLink will create uncertainty and delay pipeline construction. “We are Wet’suwet’en. We are the highest authority on our territory,” he said. “The world is watching.”
Adam Gagnon, a wing chief (sub-chief) of the Laksamshu clan, said Ms. George, Ms. Glaim and Ms. Tait-Day were justifiably stripped of their “tainted” titles, describing them as “self-proclaimed hereditary chiefs" who didn’t follow protocols to obtain their Indigenous names in the first place.
“It’s way more complicated. In our culture, the way my mother explained it to me, any woman who goes after a high chief’s name is a very greedy woman,” Mr. Gagnon said.
WET’SUWET’EN NATION
The Wet'suwet'en Nation comprises five clans
and 13 house groups in the British Columbia
Interior. A non-profit society, the Office of the
Wet’suwet’en, represents the interests of
hereditary chiefs in the area.
Wet’suwet’en Hereditary Chiefs
GIL_SEYHU
Clan name
(Big Frog Clan)
Hereditary
title
Goohlaht
Yex T’sa wit’ant’
House name
(Thin House)
Knedebeas
Unist’ot’en
is affiliated
with
Dark House
Yex T’sa wil_
k’us
(Dark House)
Samooh
Kayex
(Birchbark House)
GITDUMDEN
LAKSILYU
(Small Frog Clan)
(Wolf and Bear Clan)
Wah Tah Kwets
Woos
Kwen Beegh Yex
Cassyex
(House Beside the Fire)
(Grizzly House)
Hagwilnegh
Gisday’wa
G’en egh l_a yex
Kaiyexweniits
(House of Many Eyes)
(House in the Middle
of Many)
Wah Tah K’eght
Tsee K’al K’e yex
Madeek
(House on a Flat Rock)
Anaskaski
(Where it Lies
Blocking the Trail)
TSAYU
LAKSAMSHU
(Beaver Clan)
(Fireweed and Owl Clan)
Kloum Khun
Kwees
Medzeyex
Djakanyex
(Beaver House)
(Owl House)
Namox
Smogelgem
Tsa K’en yex
Tsaiyex
(Rafters on
Beaver House)
(Sun House)
Note: In this version of the chart, the order of the
clans has been stacked due to space considerations.
JOHN SOPINSKI/THE GLOBE AND MAIL
SOURCE: wetsuweten.com
WET’SUWET’EN NATION
The Wet'suwet'en Nation comprises five clans and 13
house groups in the British Columbia Interior.
A non-profit society, the Office of the Wet’suwet’en,
represents the interests of hereditary chiefs in the area.
Wet’suwet’en Hereditary Chiefs
GIL_SEYHU
Clan name
(Big Frog Clan)
Hereditary
title
Goohlaht
Yex T’sa wit’ant’
House name
(Thin House)
Knedebeas
Unist’ot’en
is affiliated
with
Dark House
Yex T’sa wil_
k’us
(Dark House)
Samooh
Kayex
(Birchbark House)
LAKSILYU
GITDUMDEN
(Small Frog Clan)
(Wolf and Bear Clan)
Wah Tah Kwets
Woos
Kwen Beegh Yex
Cassyex
(House Beside the Fire)
(Grizzly House)
Hagwilnegh
Gisday’wa
G’en egh l_a yex
Kaiyexweniits
(House of Many Eyes)
(House in the Middle
of Many)
Wah Tah K’eght
Tsee K’al K’e yex
Madeek
(House on a Flat Rock)
Anaskaski
(Where it Lies
Blocking the Trail)
TSAYU
LAKSAMSHU
(Beaver Clan)
(Fireweed and Owl Clan)
Kloum Khun
Kwees
Medzeyex
Djakanyex
(Beaver House)
(Owl House)
Namox
Smogelgem
Tsa K’en yex
Tsaiyex
(Rafters on
Beaver House)
(Sun House)
Note: In this version of the chart, the order of the
clans has been stacked due to space considerations.
JOHN SOPINSKI/THE GLOBE AND MAIL, SOURCE: wetsuweten.com
WET’SUWET’EN NATION
The Wet'suwet'en Nation comprises five clans and 13 house groups in the British
Columbia Interior. A non-profit society, the Office of the Wet’suwet’en, represents
the interests of hereditary chiefs in the area.
Wet’suwet’en Hereditary Chiefs
GILSEYHU
LAKSILYU
GITDUMDEN
Clan name
(Big Frog Clan)
(Small Frog Clan)
(Wolf and Bear Clan)
Hereditary
title
Goohlaht
Wah Tah Kwets
Woos
Yex T’sa wit’ant’
Kwen Beegh Yex
Cassyex
House name
(Thin House)
(House Beside the Fire)
(Grizzly House)
Knedebeas
Unist’ot’en
is affiliated
with
Dark House
Hagwilnegh
Gisday’wa
Yex T’sa wil_
k’us
G’en egh l_a yex
Kaiyexweniits
(House of Many Eyes)
(House in the
Middle of Many)
(Dark House)
Wah Tah K’eght
Samooh
Madeek
Tsee K’al K’e yex
Kayex
Anaskaski
(House on a Flat Rock)
(Birchbark House)
(Where it Lies
Blocking the Trail)
TSAYU
LAKSAMSHU
(Beaver Clan)
(Fireweed and Owl Clan)
Kloum Khun
Kwees
Note: In this
version of
the chart, the
order of the
clans has been
stacked due to
space consider-
ations.
Medzeyex
Djakanyex
(Beaver House)
(Owl House)
Na’Moks
Smogelgem
Tsa K’en yex
Tsaiyex
(Rafters on
Beaver House)
(Sun House)
JOHN SOPINSKI/THE GLOBE AND MAIL, SOURCE: wetsuweten.com
WET’SUWET’EN NATION
The Wet'suwet'en Nation comprises five clans and 13 house groups in the British Columbia Interior.
A non-profit society, the Office of the Wet’suwet’en, represents the interests of hereditary chiefs in the area.
Wet’suwet’en Hereditary Chiefs
LAKSILYU
TSAYU
LAKSAMSHU
GITDUMDEN
GILSEYHU
Clan name
(Big Frog Clan)
(Small Frog Clan)
(Beaver Clan)
(Fireweed and Owl Clan)
(Wolf and Bear Clan)
Hereditary
title
Kloum Khun
Goohlaht
Wah Tah Kwets
Kwees
Woos
Yex T’sa wit’ant’
Kwen Beegh Yex
Djakanyex
Cassyex
Medzeyex
House name
(Thin House)
(House Beside the Fire)
(Grizzly House)
(Beaver House)
(Owl House)
Knedebeas
Unist’ot’en
is affiliated
with
Dark House
Hagwilnegh
Na’Moks
Smogelgem
Gisday’wa
Yex T’sa wil_
k’us
G’en egh l_a yex
Tsa K’en yex
Kaiyexweniits
Tsaiyex
(House of Many Eyes)
(Rafters on
Beaver House)
(Sun House)
(House in the Middle
of Many)
(Dark House)
Wah Tah K’eght
Samooh
Tsee K’al K’e yex
Kayex
Madeek
(House on a Flat Rock)
(Birchbark House)
Anaskaski
(Where it Lies Blocking
the Trail)
JOHN SOPINSKI/THE GLOBE AND MAIL, SOURCE: wetsuweten.com
WET’SUWET’EN NATION
Unist’ot’en is affiliated with Dark House, one of 13 hereditary house groups under the Wet’suwet’en Nation in British Columbia’s
Interior. A non-profit society, the Office of the Wet’suwet’en, represents the interests of hereditary chiefs in the area.
Wet’suwet’en Hereditary Chiefs
LAKSILYU
TSAYU
LAKSAMSHU
GITDUMDEN
GILSEYHU
Clan name
(Big Frog Clan)
(Small Frog Clan)
(Beaver Clan)
(Fireweed and Owl Clan)
(Wolf and Bear Clan)
Hereditary
title
Kloum Khun
Goohlaht
Wah Tah Kwets
Kwees
Woos
Yex T’sa wit’ant’
Kwen Beegh Yex
Djakanyex
Cassyex
Medzeyex
House name
(Thin House)
(House Beside the Fire)
(Grizzly House)
(Beaver House)
(Owl House)
Knedebeas
Unist’ot’en
is affiliated
with
Dark House
Hagwilnegh
Na’Moks
Smogelgem
Gisday’wa
Yex T’sa wil_
k’us
G’en egh l_a yex
Tsa K’en yex
Tsaiyex
Kaiyexweniits
(House of Many Eyes)
(Rafters on
Beaver House)
(Sun House)
(House in the Middle
of Many)
(Dark House)
Wah Tah K’eght
Samooh
Tsee K’al K’e yex
Kayex
Madeek
(Birchbark House)
(House on a Flat Rock)
Anaskaski
(Where it Lies Blocking
the Trail)
JOHN SOPINSKI/THE GLOBE AND MAIL, SOURCE: wetsuweten.com
Dawson
Creek
ALASKA
Site of protests near Morice River
Houston
Kitimat
ALTA.
Prince
George
16
BRITISH
COLUMBIA
Banks
Island
97
Unist’ot’en
Camp
0
80
KM
Morice River
Kamloops
Morice River
Bridge
Coastal GasLink’s
pipeline project
Morice R. Forest Service Rd.
TransCanada’s
existing gas
transmission
system
0
1
KM
JOHN SOPINSKI/THE GLOBE AND MAIL
source: b.c. rcmp; thetyee.ca
Dawson
Creek
ALASKA
Site of protests near Morice River
Houston
ALTA.
Kitimat
Prince
George
16
BRITISH
COLUMBIA
Banks
Island
97
Unist’ot’en
Camp
0
80
KM
Morice River
Kamloops
Morice River
Bridge
Coastal GasLink’s
pipeline project
Morice River Forest Service Rd.
TransCanada’s
existing gas
transmission
system
0
1
KM
JOHN SOPINSKI/THE GLOBE AND MAIL, source: b.c. rcmp;
thetyee.ca
Dawson
Creek
ALASKA
Site of protests near Morice River
Houston
ALTA.
Kitimat
Prince
George
Haida
Gwaii
16
BRITISH
COLUMBIA
Banks
Island
97
Unist’ot’en
Camp
0
80
KM
Morice River
Kamloops
Morice River
Bridge
Coastal GasLink’s
pipeline project
Morice River Forest Service Rd.
TransCanada’s
existing gas
transmission
system
0
1
KM
JOHN SOPINSKI/THE GLOBE AND MAIL, source: b.c. rcmp; thetyee.ca